Skip to content
The Socratic Hearth

Questions Education · learning environments

Should students be allowed to use AI chatbots for homework?

Chatbots can now write an essay or solve a problem set in seconds, and schools have answered with everything from bans to lessons on how to use them.

A new question on the shelf

Write your position on this Read the two starter cards

Two starter cards

Written for the hearth so this question has a whole card on each side to argue with. No visitor wrote them, so the two parts only a person can fill are empty: what happened to you, and who on the other side called the case against fair.

Yes, if taught

Where this card stands
Yes, if they are taught how. Students will use these tools at work, so school should teach when they help, when they are wrong, and how to show their own thinking.
How sure, before and after the case against
60%50%
The strongest case against it
Homework is practice. A tool that writes the answer removes the practice, and students who lean on it never learn the skill the homework was for.
What would change this card’s mind
If students allowed chatbots for homework did worse on tests taken without them.
What happened to you
Empty on a starter card.
Called fair by someone on the other side
Nobody yet. Only a person can fill this.

Argue with this card

Not for practice

Where this card stands
Not for practice work. Keep chatbots out of homework meant to build a skill, and use them in class, where a teacher can see how they are used.
How sure, before and after the case against
60%50%
The strongest case against it
A ban at home doesn’t stop use. It teaches students to hide it, and students with no help at home fall further behind.
What would change this card’s mind
If schools that banned chatbots for homework saw as much hidden use as schools that allowed them.
What happened to you
Empty on a starter card.
Called fair by someone on the other side
Nobody yet. Only a person can fill this.

Argue with this card

“Argue with this card” opens the card on the front page with this card’s position as the case against you. You write where you stand and what would change your mind.

More in Education

Next on the shelf

Is housing a need, or a strategy for meeting needs of shelter, safety, and belonging?

Every question, by domain