Skip to content
The Socratic Hearth

Questions Health · public health

Should the library stay open until 9 p.m. during heat alerts?

The worst heat of a heat wave often lasts into the evening, after most public buildings close. This is the question the Institute uses to show how a town’s question moves from a position to a group record.

The Futurism Institute’s worked example

Write your position on this Read the two starter cards

Two starter cards

Written for the hearth so this question has a whole card on each side to argue with. No visitor wrote them, so the two parts only a person can fill are empty: what happened to you, and who on the other side called the case against fair.

Yes

Where this card stands
Yes. The heat lasts into the evening, and a cool public room with water and seats protects people who have no air conditioning at home.
How sure, before and after the case against
75%65%
The strongest case against it
Late hours cost staff time and money that could fund cooling centres where the people most at risk actually live, and a library isn’t built for that job.
What would change this card’s mind
If evening visitors during heat alerts were mostly regular library users, not people without cooling at home.
What happened to you
Empty on a starter card.
Called fair by someone on the other side
Nobody yet. Only a person can fill this.

Argue with this card

No

Where this card stands
No. Open a cooling centre with medical staff and transport, and keep the library’s money for books, programmes and daytime hours.
How sure, before and after the case against
50%45%
The strongest case against it
People already know where the library is and trust it. A new cooling centre nobody has heard of stands empty on the hottest night.
What would change this card’s mind
If cooling centres in comparable towns were used by fewer people than libraries kept open late.
What happened to you
Empty on a starter card.
Called fair by someone on the other side
Nobody yet. Only a person can fill this.

Argue with this card

“Argue with this card” opens the card on the front page with this card’s position as the case against you. You write where you stand and what would change your mind.

More in Health

Next on the shelf

Should children be allowed to play tackle football?

Every question, by domain